Episodes / Inaugural Season / 29
Episode 29 · Commentary

Don't Just Sit There, Persuade Me: The Science, Art, and Magic of Persuasion

Eli AmdurInaugural season~17 min

About this episode

Eli Amdur argues that most people fail at persuasion because they rely on volume rather than strategy. He notes that two-thirds of human interaction involves persuading or being persuaded, yet many professionals lack basic methods. This episode challenges the listener to move beyond shouting and adopt a more deliberate approach to influence.

The host breaks down persuasion into three distinct layers. He explains the science of credibility, authority, and relevance. He then describes the art of gauging feedback and adjusting in real time. Finally, he explores the magic of selecting the right method, such as emotion or urgency, to make the message land effectively.

Amdur closes with two aphorisms from his career, including his own Devil's Dictionary-style definition of an organization chart in the spirit of Ambrose Bierce, and George Bernard Shaw's warning that the single biggest problem with communication is the illusion that it has occurred. The episode also includes a request for listeners to share the podcast with five friends to help the show grow.

In this episode

  • What are the three reasons humans communicate
  • How do credibility and authority differ in persuasion
  • Why is feedback considered the art of persuasion
  • What are common logical fallacies to avoid
  • How can you use emotion to persuade an audience
  • What is the biggest problem with communication according to Shaw

Eli’s Aphorisms

If you don't change, you have changed.
An organization chart is a document that explains in pictorial form how an organization is supposed to work, and then clearly exposes why it doesn't.

From Great Minds

“The single biggest problem with communication is the illusion that it has occurred.”
George Bernard Shaw

Transcript

This is Vantage Point, the podcast for critical thinkers, where we make sense of and excel in our lives, our jobs, and our world. We're not political, just critical. Thanks to the ever-growing millions of listeners for joining each week as we continue our campaign to revive critical thinking. I'm your host, Eli Amdur, happy to have you with us and looking forward to continuing our good fight together.

I'm more than happy to tell you that listenership is and has been consistently on the rise every week and that we have been launched into the top 25% of all podcasts worldwide, of which there are more than 5 million. We reach that level every week. You've just accepted what we've offered you. We are very grateful for that.

Today, we're going to talk about persuasion. Let's call this episode "Don't Just Sit There, Persuade Me: The Science, Art, and Magic of Persuasion." So let me start by saying, quick, name the three reasons that humans communicate. And if you haven't answered yet, either you haven't thought enough about it and about basic human communication, or you've overthought it.

Read the full transcript

Truth is, we communicate in verbal, written, or non-verbal modalities to persuade, to inform, or to mark special occasions. That's it: persuade, to inform, or to mark special occasions. So after a few words about informative and special occasion communication, purely for context and to get it out of the way, we're here to talk about persuasion.

Informative communication includes descriptions, narrations, explanations, recipes, product ingredients, progress reports, scientific formulas, blueprints, baseball box scores, or anything else that adds to the receiver's store of knowledge.

Special occasion communications are awards, giving or accepting them, dedications, entertainment, memorials, tributes, and that can include anything up to and including anthems, eulogies, heroic symphonies, dance, wedding speeches, cheers for a home run. In short, anything not routine is special occasion.

The wide range of things that informative and special occasion cover notwithstanding, studies have shown that of all the time we spend with others, upwards of two-thirds of it is either persuading or being persuaded. Most prominently, this includes sales, marketing, advertising, product packaging, proposals, goal setting, fundraising, and political campaigning.

Just to take one of those for example, if you think about watching TV over the course of a few hours, how many times are there attempts made to persuade you to buy a car, to vote for a candidate, to take a certain drug? That's all persuasive communication. That's all it is. So a logical question is, shouldn't we be better at what we do the most of?

Observations over 15 years of teaching graduate communication and leadership courses, which I did at Fairleigh Dickinson University from 2003 to 18, and of adapting these courses to the corporate arena, revealed two startling realities.

One, when asked in open-ended ways to name different communication reasons, 80% of the respondents either didn't name all three or invented more than three. Two, when asked to list one persuasion method, 75% of the people responding could not generate any. Many. Don't forget, that's informative, persuasive, and special occasion.

Now, I'll go into more on these methods later, but for now, to add to the dire situation, professionals in every field, sad to say, have never thought about persuasion beyond believing that it depends on who talks the loudest, longest, or last, or more to the extreme, who creates an autocratic environment and literally pounds others into submission, as was the case with heads of state all over the world over the last decade. Recent events around the globe have proven the futility of that failed approach. It hasn't worked, and in the long run, never will.

But clearly, to the enlightened, there is science, art, and magic to persuasion. Let's talk about the science of persuasion first. Persuasion depends on four factors: credibility, authority, relevance, and feedback. We generate the first three; we receive the fourth. Therefore, the first three constitute the science of persuasion, as they are planned and can be replicated. The fourth, which will be discussed later, is undeniably the art of persuasion, needing creative interpretation and artistic, even athletic, adjustment.

To be credible, an idea must be believable, sensible, and practical to some degree, or any combination thereof. What does that mean? Albert Einstein used to say, "If you can't explain something to a six-year-old, you don't know it well enough yourself." If it's not initially credible, persuaders must derive credibility by explaining it through logic, reasoning, examples, or analogies.

So if I can be authoritative and credible on my own merits, that's fine. If not, I need to quote Albert Einstein, as I do often, or anyone else who can bring credibility and authority to the table, or to quote reputable sources: the World Economic Forum, Merriam-Webster, a Walter Isaacson biography. You either have the authority or you borrow it. If we have that authority, fine. If not, we borrow it.

And then relevance. We've just talked about credibility and authority. Relevance, pretty simple to understand. It depends on an idea being significant to us, one we're liable to accept, approve of, defend, and allow to pass through our paradigm structures.

Moving on to the art of persuasion. Dealing with feedback is the artful part of persuasion. Feedback is constant and must be continuously gauged by the sender. Great speakers are constantly watching their audience, whether they're speaking to one person whom they would like to persuade to buy a product, or an audience of 5,000 people.

You must continue to gauge your message and the reception of it. For example, how is the receiver interpreting your message? How can you determine that? This is an intimate dance performed by the persuader and the persuaded that provides milestones along the path to recognition of the persuasion itself.

It's not just an end result.

It's part and parcel of the adjustment process.

It's kind of like you're the quarterback calling an audible at the line or the tennis player adjusting to your opponent's wicked serve or the stand-up comic whose stuff is not going over with him but still has five more minutes worth of stuff to do.

How astutely you recognize these scenarios and how athletically you adjust, that's how persuasive you'll be.

Let me give you a note or two about the magic of persuasion.

Making persuasion happen is where the magic comes in.

Understanding the above, it's appropriate to identify and enlist specific methods of persuasion, most common of which are logic, emotion, proof of concept, endorsement, expert testimony, urgency, reasoning, and get this, fallacies.

For this part of the topic, reference is made to www.fallacyfiles.org. That's F-A -L-A -C-Y -F-I -L-E -S.org. It's a scholarly study with more than you'll ever need to know. But the point is, though, that if you engage in fallacies, and some of the more recognizable ones are red herring, ad hominem, either or, bandwagon, slippery slope, personal belief.

You are guilty and can expect to be called out by even a mildly sophisticated listener.

And there goes your persuasion.

But when you decide on the best method for your message, for example, emotion in ads for animal rescue, you see those every 15 minutes on late night TV.

Don't give me stats and spreadsheets. Make me cry.

When you get Michael Jordan's endorsement of Nike shoes or the bandwagon approach in automobile commercials, the most famous of which is showing an automobile showroom with 40 or 50 people running around with balloons and opening car doors and everything else. That is the bandwagon. Everybody's doing it. Everybody's buying our car.

Or urgency in a task force committee meeting, that's when the magic starts. Knowing which is the best method of persuasive approach. But all in all, remember this.

We all want to be persuaded.

A little thought about a relatively simple exercise will give your audience what they want through the science, the art, and the magic of persuasion.

And here's the favor i want to ask you we've come a long way and we know we're going to go a long way but we need your help to do it faster and farther the favor i'm going to ask you is would you pick five friends business associates family members neighbors send them the link to my website, eliamdur.com, E-L -I-A -M-D -U-R.com.

Ask them to click on my podcast and listen at least to the first two episodes, the first of which spells out very clearly what we intend to do and a second of which talks about how we're going to do it. It's very important for us to ask your help on this. So let me give you a couple of clues.

Maybe you'll want to listen to and ask your friends and associates to listen to episode 18, which talks about the greatest non-decision ever made. Or number 15 and 16, which talks about hiring people, liberal arts backgrounds, or not hiring people who haven't got the skills to do the job that you're filling, what happens when you hire the wrong person. Or the episode that you just heard on persuasion, or one of my favorites, episode number 25, entitled "Intuition in the Age of Analytics."

We'd appreciate your help on this. Pick five people you know and send them to them and ask them to listen in, and ask them to do the same thing. Ask them to check out the episodes. Others, of course, we would love that. But that's the kind of help we need, and we'd very much appreciate you doing that.

In the meantime, let me finish up the way I always do by offering you a couple of aphorisms, truths, as I see it, that I've picked up along the way of a 57-year career. And the first is simple, very aphoristic in nature, and it tells you this: that if you don't change, you have changed.

And the second aphorism of the day leans on the sarcasm of Ambrose Bierce of the 19th century in America, who wrote The Devil's Dictionary. And I give you my take on one thing, and I've got a few more of these as we move along together. What's an organization chart? An organization chart is a document that explains in pictorial form how an organization is supposed to work, and then clearly exposes why it doesn't.

And I'm going to sign off with this offering from one of the great minds that we recognize, and that's George Bernard Shaw. It comes appropriately at the end of this episode, which deals with communication and specifically persuasion. Shaw said the single biggest problem with communication is the illusion that it has occurred.

And lastly, I don't know who said this, but I have my guess, but it's this thought: we think we are thinking when all we're doing is rearranging our prejudices. If you have your guess, let me know.

Thanks for spending time with me. I'm Eli Amdur. See you next time. Until then, keep questioning, keep learning and keep thinking critically.

Transcript auto-generated from the episode audio and lightly edited for readability.

Who’s out there? Six quick questions, about a minute, completely anonymous — no name, no email. It helps us make a better show.

Answer six quick questions ›